I disagree because someone sharing their opinion does not limit others from accessing the content.
That’s not what gatekeeping in fandom is. Gatekeeping is to claim that either some content is not real <franchise> or that some fan is not a real fan of <franchise> because of <opinion>. That is exactly what OP did by claiming that Discovery was not ‘real Trek’. They then listed stuff that were personal opinions and ways that they felt about the show as an example of why it isn’t Real Trek. They then changed tact entirely when the gatekeeping was pointed out and admitted they were wrong.
They were gatekeeping. This isn’t a matter of opinion, that was a matter of fact. You can disagree with that but you’d be wrong. Gatekeeping has no business in any franchise, nevermind Star Trek.
That’s not what gatekeeping in fandom is. Gatekeeping is to claim that either some content is not real <franchise> or that some fan is not a real fan of <franchise> because of <opinion>. That is exactly what OP did by claiming that Discovery was not ‘real Trek’. They then listed stuff that were personal opinions and ways that they felt about the show as an example of why it isn’t Real Trek. They then changed tact entirely when the gatekeeping was pointed out and admitted they were wrong.
They were gatekeeping. This isn’t a matter of opinion, that was a matter of fact. You can disagree with that but you’d be wrong. Gatekeeping has no business in any franchise, nevermind Star Trek.
Edit.meh this isn’t worth it
I’ll edit and close by saying I DO agree with your final sentence. That is very true.